Fouling In Heat Exchangers: A Costly Problem
The deposition of material on heat transfer surfaces is called fouling, which significantly impacts the thermal and mechanical performance of heat exchangers. Fouling increases the overall thermal resistance and lowers the overall heat transfer coefficient of heat exchangers as well as impedes fluid flow, accelerates corrosion, and increases pressure drop across the heat exchanger. The cleaning of fouled heat exchangers presents a significant challenge to maintenance and operation of heat exchangers in process industries.
The common fouling mechanisms are:
- Particulate fouling – resulting from sediment of dust, rust, fine solids and other entrained solids.
- Crystallization fouling - Calcium carbonate is the predominant component of the hard and tenacious scale deposit from water and is particularly apparent in processes involving heat transfer. A concentration of dissolved solids by repeated partial evaporation of the water is the main factor that causes calcium carbonate scale. Even soft water will eventually become scale forming when concentrated numerous times, i.e. two, three, four, or even higher.
- Biological fouling – Occurs when biological organisms grow on heat exchanger surfaces. Problems can be caused by algae and other microbes such as barnacles and zebra mussels. At certain times of the year when microbes are said to bloom, colonies several inches thick may grow across the heat exchanger service, affecting thermal performance.
- Chemical reaction fouling – This type of fouling occurs when the depositions are formed as a result of a chemical reaction.
- Corrosion fouling – Results from a chemical reaction that involves the heat exchanger surface material.
Costs for extra fuel occur when fouling leads to extra fuel burning in boilers and furnaces or when other energy such as electricity or process steam is needed to overcome the effects of fouling. It is calculated that additional fuel and energy costs equate to billions of dollars each year.
Additional costs are attributed to maintenance charges for the removal of fouling deposits. Manufacturers of heat exchangers state that 15 percent of all factory maintenance costs are credited to heat exchangers and of that 50 percent is due to fouling. Add the costs of plant shutdown for days at a time, and the effect of fouling is only too plain.
There are now four popular methods of removing fouling:
- Mechanical cleaning, which involves brushing and scraping.
- Chemical cleaning, which uses solvents or chemicals.
- High velocity cleaning using water jets.
- Electronic water treatment.
Electronic Water Treatment Trials
Research carried out at Cranfield University in the United Kingdom identified conditions under which magnetic treatment can lead to a maximum of 70 percent reduction in calcium carbonate scale formation. The degree to which scale formation is inhibited has been identified to be dependent on a number of physicochemical conditions such as temperature, pH, hardness, and alkalinity.
During 2006-2007, Uniquest, an independent consulting and research company in Queensland, Australia was engaged to carry out laboratory investigations and testing on the heat exchanger tubes. An electronic water treatment device was installed onto a manifest heat exchanger. At the end of the 12-month period, it was found that no hard scale had formed on samples during the period of the trial – nor was there any biofouling slime, corrosion, or calcite sludge.
Electronic Scale Removal
In process industries, it is common for chemicals to be added to water either because the water is being used for ‘scrubbing’ or cleaning, or to achieve a chemical mineral effect as part of the production process. This inevitably leads to limescale deposition. Scaling deposits are common in flowlines subject to changes of pressure or temperature. Regardless of how hard water effects are achieved, the outcome is the same: Scale formation results in reduced diameter or blocked pipes, reduced heat transfer efficiency, seized pumps, inoperarable valves, misleading meter readings, and defective heating elements.
To explain the effect of electronic scale removal, it is first important to understand the major factors that cause scale. While scale can be a complex of many minerals, calcium carbonate is the most prevalent in industrial processes.
Aqueous solutions can become supersaturated, which means that they contain higher concentrations of dissolved solute than their equilibrium concentration. Such solutions are not stable and are easily triggered into dropping back to saturation level, forcing the dissolved compound to precipitate. Even when a bulk solution is less than fully saturated, scale formation can occur spontaneously due to localized super saturation, at a surface for example.
pH Effect on Scale Formation
The pH of the solution is directly related to its acid content (typically carbonic acid). The higher the acid content, the lower the pH number. The solubility of calcium carbonate is directly affected by the pH of the water. If the pH of the water is decreased, more calcium carbonate solid can be dissolved. Conversely, if the pH of the water rises, it will force calcium carbonate out of solution and hence scale deposits will form.
Temperature Effect on Scale Formation
Gases in general, and specifically carbon dioxide, are less soluble in water at high temperatures. Therefore, as the temperature rises, the dissolved carbon dioxide decreases. This increases the pH of the fluid, reducing the solubility of the calcium carbonate and forcing the mineral to deposit.
Pressure Effects on Scale Formation
Carbon dioxide and gases in general are more soluble under higher pressure. Therefore, as the pressure drops, carbon dioxide gas will be forced out of solution, lowering the carbonic acid concentration. The rise in pH is associated with a drop in calcium carbonate solubility, leading to the formation of mineral scale deposits.
Electronic Water Conditioning
Electronic Water Treatment (EWT) is a non-invasive system utilizing a solenoid coil or coils wrapped around the pipework to be treated. A continuously frequency changing signal generator, within a specified range, supplies current to the coils. The pulse shaped current creates an induced electric field, concentric around the axis inside the pipe. As a consequence to this arrangement, any charged particle or ion moving within the field experiences a so-called Lorentz force generated by the interaction between charged particles and magnetic and electric fields.
The treatment influences the initial nucleation, resulting in crystals that do not "stick" together. Untreated water builds up matted structures that continuously grow. This treatment creates idiomorphic, scattered crystals, which do not form matted structures. They have a rotundas shape, which means that they have a larger volume in relation to a smaller surface. This feature makes them sensitive to water currents and they are easily flushed out of the pipeline. As no new scale layers are formed, the sheer force of the water flow will gradually remove existing layers of scale. The ability to adjust power, frequency, and coil configurations of products like the Scalewatcher on site enables performance to be optimized with no downtime and no pipe replacement.
Biological Fouling Is Also Successfully Treated With EWT
The impact of zebra mussels extends from the Great Lakes watershed to the mouth of the Mississippi River. The mussels affect industry by clogging pipes and intake structure. Crustaceans and zebra mussels are similar in the way they use calcium—a key component of pipe scaling. They both convert calcium in a free ion form to calcium carbonate to construct their shell or exoskeleton. A study undertaken by Aquatic Sciences, Inc. – an international underwater inspection service – found that EWT technology was successful in removing calcium carbonate and thereby drastically reducing the level of zebra mussel infestation.
The fouling of heat exchangers in processing industries is a chronic operating problem. Costs due to additional fuel consumption and maintenance, loss of production, etc. have been estimated as 0.25 percent of the GNP of industrialized countries. EWT offers companies an environmental, effective, and cost saving method of reducing fouling on heat exchangers which can only prove a win, win, win scenario for all.
The Scalewatcher is an environmentally friendly alternative to chemical and mechanical descaling. Launched in the 1980’s it has successfully treated hard water problems for industrial manufacturers as well as water companies, oil producers, farmers, horticulturists, shipping companies, shopping centers, school, universities and government establishments.